High Court Judgments of Public Interest

This page provides access to judgments of the High Court in the last 90 days deemed to be of particular public interest.

More information about finding court judgments is available on the Judgments section of this website.

It is the responsibility of users of the information contained in these decisions to ensure compliance with conditions or other legal obligations governing access, release, storage and re-publication. See also the guide on statutory provisions that prohibit publication of certain information in certain circumstances (PDF, 211 KB). If in doubt you should consult the court that issued the decision(s). Judicial decisions are presented in PDF format to preserve the integrity of the documents.

 

Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 3363
Date of Judgment
29 October 2026
Summary

Sentencing of Mr Pongia for murder and causing grievous bodily harm. Charges arising out of a singular incident where Mr Pongia stabbed two victims, causing one's death. Life imprisonment manifestly unjust given Mr Pongia's age, the impulsive nature of the offending and prospect of rehabilitation. Starting point of 30 years' imprisonment adopted. 15 percent discount for guilty plea, 25 percent discount for age, background and prospect of rehabilitation. No discount for remorse. End sentence of 18 years' imprisonment with a nine-year minimum period.

Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 3426
Date of Judgment
23 October 2026
Summary

Sentencing of aunt (A) for manslaughter by omission to provide necessaries to six year-old niece (D) (Crimes Act 1961, ss 160(2)(b), 150A and 152).

D had complex medical needs. D developed concerning symptoms during three days in A"s care. A texted D's mother (M) about symptoms but neither took D to hospital. D highly likely not to have died if given prompt medical attention.

Starting point of 4 years adopted. Relevant factors: serious long-term harm, D's vulnerability, breach of trust, temporal extent of inaction.

Allowances of 25% given for guilty plea, 15% for impact imprisonment would have on other children (A single mother of two vulnerable children), 5% for remorse, 10% for upbringing.

Nominal end sentence of 1 year and 9 months' imprisonment.

Held, home detention appropriate. Offending very context-specific and greater societal interest in remaining with children given their circumstances.

Sentence of 10 months' home detention imposed.

See R v M [2026] NZHC 3425 for sentencing of sister.

Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 3425
Date of Judgment
23 October 2026
Summary

Sentencing of mother (M) for manslaughter by omission to provide necessaries to six-year-old daughter (D) (Crimes Act 1961, ss 160(2)(b), 150A and 152). D had complex medical needs. M knew certain symptoms meant D needed urgent medical attention. D developed symptoms over three days in care of M’s sister [A]. M and A texted each other about them by neither took D to hospital. D likely not to have died if given prompt medical attention.

Starting point of four years and three months adopted. Relevant factors: D’s vulnerability, breach of trust, serious long-term harm, temporal extent of inaction. Reduced slightly to account for M’s mental health issues at time.

Allowance of 25% given for guilty plea, 10% of background, 10% for remorse and rehabilitation, 10% for impact imprisonment would have on other children (M single mother).

Nominal end sentence of 1 year and 11 months’ imprisonment.

Held, home detention appropriate. Offending very context-specific and greater societal interest in M remaining with other children.

Sentence of 12 months home detention imposed.

See R v A [2026] NZHC 3426 for sentencing of sister.

 

Case number
[2026] NZHC 3302
Date of Judgment
22 October 2026
Summary

The Dog Lovers of Monte Cecilia Society sought judicial review of the Puketapapa Local Board's decision to designate the entirety of Monte Cecilia Park in Hillsborough/Mt Roskill as an on-leash area for dogs, removing the off-leash area that had existed in the park's bowl since 2016. In December 2024, the Puketapapa Local Board consulted on a proposal to make the entire park an on-leash area. Despite overwhelmingly negative feedback (but a small population of the board's population overall), the Board resolved on 17 April 2025 to proceed with the change and declined to reverse that decision in June 2025. The Society challenged the lawfulness of the decision and sought an order quashing it.

HELD: Application dismissed. The Board's decisions were lawful. The removal of the off-leash area was within the Board's delegated authority and was neither ultra vires nor inconsistent with any legitimate expectation. The Board did not fail to consider relevant matters, including practicable alternatives and access to other areas for displaced dogs and their owners. Nor was there evidence of predetermination or that the Board failed to approach either decision with an open mind. Neither decision was unreasonable in the administrative law sense. The outcome was one the Board was entitled to reach.

Case number
[2026] NZHC 3244
Date of Judgment
22 October 2026
Summary

District Māori Councils (DMCs), and by extension the applicant, have exclusive power and authority to control and supervise the activities of Māori Wardens in their districts (Māori Community Development Act, ss 16(5) and s 7(5)). The power is not confined to controlling and supervising the exercise of powers conferred on Māori Wardens under ss 31 to 35 of the Act to manage disorder and

alcohol consumption. The funding is for the Trust to govern, manage and deliver the general statutory duties and functions of Māori Wardens without the involvement of the applicant or the DMCs. The Crown has exercised a degree of control over the Trust's activities by providing the funding required to undertake them, and imposing obligations on how they must be performed as a condition of that

funding. The funding agreement is contrary to the Act as it encroaches on the applicant's/OM Cs' exclusive power and authority to control and supervise Māori Wardens carrying out their general duties under the Act.

Application granted. Order declaring decision to enter funding agreement as unlawful.

Case number
[2026] NZHC 3248
Date of Judgment
21 October 2026
Summary

Application for judicial review of decision to promulgate regulations prohibiting new prescriptions of puberty blockers for children or adolescents with gender incongruence or gender dysphoria.

Held: Application granted. Insufficient consultation on the substance of the regulations and failure to consult directly with gender diverse young people. Indefinite prohibition of access to puberty blockers for new patients was a breach of right to freedom from discrimination on the prohibited ground of disability. Minister did not abdicate decision-making power to Cabinet or act for an improper purpose given the evidence he made the decision himself after consultation with Cabinet.

Media Release
Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 2943
Date of Judgment
25 September 2026
Summary

Audrey Thompson sentenced to life imprisonment with a 10-year minimum period of imprisonment for the murder of friend’s partner by stabbing him twice in the neck with a broken bottle. The Court considered a minimum period of imprisonment of 10 years, the statutory minimum, was appropriate having regard to the aggravating factors present (deliberate creation of a lethal weapon out of a nearby beer bottle; the use of that lethal weapon twice; and the fact the strike was to the deceased’s neck, a very vulnerable part of the human body); comparable decisions; and allowances given for Ms Thompson’s prior good character, her PTSD and background trauma, and the time she had spent on EM bail.

Case number
[2026] NZHC 2887
Date of Judgment
24 September 2026
Summary

Application for judicial review of decision to extradite applicant to China to face murder charge.

Held: Application declined. Reasonable basis for Minister to be satisfied no sufficiently material change in circumstances since Supreme court decision to require wider reconsideration of extradition. Comprehensive diplomatic assurances remain effective. Differences in foreign policy have not impacted years of law enforcement cooperation. Further rejection of Western ideas not a material change to position known to the Supreme Court. Obstruction of United Nations inquiry does not make monitoring assurances ineffective. No material change to risk of doctors being unlikely to report torture.

Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 2828
Date of Judgment
17 September 2026
Summary

Sentencing of Mr L for 34 serious violent and sexual offending. Victims of the offending included Mr L's children, his stepchild and former partner. Aggravating factors include a significant breach of trust, victim vulnerability, a climate of control, use of object for sexual offending, victim harm, and cruelty.

Held: Sentence of preventive detention imposed. Minimum period of eight years' imprisonment. Considerable history of sexual and violent history showing a pattern of serious offending. Expert reports indicate a tendency to commit serious violence offences in the future. Absence of failure to address the cause of the offending. Not satisfied Mr L will engage in rehabilitation.

Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 2750
Date of Judgment
09 September 2026
Summary

Sentencing for manslaughter - single stabbing in the course of a mutual fist-fight. Starting point 6.5 years. Uplift for offending while subject to sentence and for history of violence offending (4 months). Discounts of 20 and 10 per cent for guilty plea and background factors respectively. End sentence 4 years and 10 months' imprisonment. First strike warning issued.

Case number
[2026] NZHC 2716
Date of Judgment
07 September 2026
Summary

Dispute between liquidators of Mainzeal and insurer QBE as to insurance monies payable under D&O policy for damages for directors’ breach of duties (ordered by SC in 2023). Issue one whether $1M payable under extension (for Mr Yan as non-executive director) excluded by personal profit exclusion. Issue two whether QBE must indemnify Mainzeal for GST payable on receipt under s 5(13) GST Act and whether Mainzeal must structure its receipt so as not to incur GST liability.

Held: $1M under extension not within exclusion clause because of prescriptive and narrow requirements of clause; Mainzeal not indemnified for GST payable on receipt of insurance monies. Exclusion requires final judgment ‘determining’ insured committed wrongful act (breach of duty) intended to gain personal profit/advantage not legally entitled to and in fact gained which must be material to cause of action adjudicated – acts material to breach must intend to and in fact result in personal profit/advantage. SC judgment ‘final’ but HC and CA findings relevant if unchallenged, ‘in fact’ means evidentiary threshold not equivocal findings. No finding of personal profit/advantage in relevant breach period;  material to breach was directors’ failure to recognise risk without binding support/capital; limited actions to reduce risk; and obligations entered with no reasonable grounds of being honoured. HC held Yan benefitted from funds extracted but that state of affairs occurred prior to breach date, acts/omissions required under exclusion are distinct from existing state of affairs. GST indemnity only applies to ‘the insured’ meaning the insured claiming cover under policy, Mainzeal received payment as third-party claimant not as an ‘insured’. No duty to structure payment in tax-efficient manner, indemnity triggered by GST liability incurred by ‘the insured’ on receipt. Whether proposed two-step process realistic unnecessary to determine.

 

Case number
[2026] NZHC 2715
Date of Judgment
07 September 2026
Summary

Dispute whether Mainzeal’s receipt of indemnity payment under D&O policy for damages for directors’ breach of duties (ordered by SC in 2023) subject to GST under s 5(13) GST Act. Section 5(13) provides GST payable on payment under contract of insurance, whether or not party to contract, that relates to loss incurred in taxable activity. Held: GST payable on Mainzeal’s receipt of indemnity payment. Section amended in 2000 to ensure insurance payments to registered third parties are subject to output tax in hands of third party. ‘Under contract of insurance’ means receipt which contractually entitled to but ‘whether or not party to contract’ alters requirement for contractual relationship. ‘Relates to loss incurred’ not confined to insured’s loss but includes loss incurred in furtherance of taxable activity. Despite internally inconsistent language, intention of amendment clear to impose GST liability on third parties on actual receipt of a payment made under a contract of insurance.

Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 2699
Date of Judgment
04 September 2026
Summary

Toni-Ashley Crawford sentenced for the murder of Teri Rhind following jury trial. Ms Crawford conducted a U-turn, crossed centre line and accelerated to strike victim with her vehicle.

Held: Sentence of life imprisonment imposed with a minimum period of imprisonment of 10 years.

Circumstances did not make a sentence of life imprisonment manifestly unjust. Aggravating factors of manner of driving, use of a weapon, vulnerability of victim, callousness and post-offending conduct and extent of loss, damage and harm. Personal mitigating factors of personal background, mental health and addiction. Ms Crawford likely experiencing methamphetamine-induced psychosis at time of offending.

Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 2667
Date of Judgment
03 September 2026
Summary

Manslaughter sentencing. Defendant lit fire killing deceased. Defendant suffers intellectual difficulties. Crown accepted plea of guilty to manslaughter and abandoned murder charge. Six year starting point adopted given intellectual difficulties. Final sentence five years’ imprisonment.

Case number
[2026] NZHC 2654
Date of Judgment
02 September 2026
Summary

Application under s 317 of the Property Law Act 2007 for modification of a covenant so it no longer burdens the applicant’s land.

HELD: Change in character of the neighbourhood since registration; covenant impeded the reasonable use of the burdened land; and no substantial injury to the benefiting owners; application granted.

Case number
[2026] NZHC 2670
Date of Judgment
01 September 2026
Summary

Mr Hannon McGinn and Mr Howe sentenced after being found guilty of murder by jury. Mr Hannon McGinn additionally pleaded guilty to arson, while the jury found Mr Howe guilty of same. Court satisfied that life sentence would not be manifestly unjust under s 102 of the Sentencing Act 2002. Court also satisfied that ss 104(1)(e) and 104(1)(g) engaged but found that a 17 year minimum period of imprisonment would be manifestly unjust.

Starting point for Mr Hannon McGinn was a minimum period of imprisonment of 14 years. Reductions available for remorse and traumatic background with causal connection with the offending. End sentence of life imprisonment with a 13-year minimum period of imprisonment. Firearms prohibition order made under s 39A(1)(a) of the Arms Act 1983.

Starting point for Mr Howe was a minimum period of imprisonment of 12 years. Reductions available for remorse, time spent on EM bail, as well as psychological processing difficulties. End sentence of life imprisonment with a 10 year 4 month minimum period of imprisonment. Firearms prohibition order made under s 39A(1)(a) of the Arms Act.

On the charge of arson, Mr Hannon McGinn and Mr Howe sentenced to seven years' imprisonment to be served concurrently.

Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 2570
Date of Judgment
27 August 2026
Summary

The defendant appeared for sentence on their guilty pleas to murder in culmination of five breaches (one representative) of a protection order made in favour of the victim, who was the defendant’s former partner. The defendant, while on bail awaiting sentence for two of the admitted breach of protection order charges, had entered the victim’s home unannounced, stabbing them 13 times. On the murder conviction, the Court found the Sentencing Act 2002’s s 104(1A)(c), (d), (e) and (h) factors were engaged, and sentenced the defendant to life imprisonment with a minimum period of imprisonment of 17 years. On the protection order convictions, the Court sentenced the defendant to six years and nine months’ imprisonment, to be served concurrently.

Case name
Case number
[2026] NZHC 2563
Date of Judgment
26 August 2026
Summary

Hao Feng sentenced to a term of four years and two months' imprisonment for the manslaughter of his partner by manual strangulation. The Court imposed a starting point of seven years' imprisonment, having regard to the aggravating factors present (harm caused to others; vulnerability of the neck; breach of trust within an intimate partner relationship; and failure to seek medical assistance), comparable decisions, and the leading cases on non-fatal strangulation, Shramka v R [2022) NZCA 299, [2022) 3 NZLR 348, and non­fatal serious violent offending, R v Taueki [2005) 3 NZLR 372 (CA). Total allowances of 40 per cent granted comprising reductions for guilty pleas (20 per cent); remorse (five per cent); hardship in being imprisoned as a foreign national speaking no English (five per cent); and personal circumstances including the impact of the offending on the defendant's children (10 per cent).

Case number
[2026] NZHC 2529
Date of Judgment
25 August 2026
Summary

Sentencing for Kaixiao Liu and Lanyue Xiao in respect of offending connected with the death of Shulai Wang.

Mr Liu given a starting point of 11 years' imprisonment for kidnapping/manslaughter charges and an 18 month uplift for the attempting to pervert justice and misconduct with human remains charges. Ms Xiao given a starting point of eight years, six months' imprisonment for the kidnapping/manslaughter charges and a 15 month uplift for the attempting to pervert justice and misconduct with human remains charges.

Defendants each given a five per cent discount for impact on children, five per cent discount for good character and 10 month reduction for time spent on EM bail.

Case number
[2026] NZHC 2519
Date of Judgment
25 August 2026
Summary

Urgent application for an interim injunction and prospective costs. The applicant seeks to restrain the trustees of Toi Foundation, a charitable trust, from voting on a proposed sale of shares in TSB Bank and requiring it to apply for directions under s 133 of the Trusts Act 2019 ahead of any such vote.

Held: Persons who my receive a benefit from a charitable trust are excluded from the meaning of "beneficiary" in the Trusts Act. The applicant is thus not a beneficiary and does not have standing to bring review under ss 126-127 of the Trusts Act. Nor can the claim be brought under the Court's inherent jurisdiction. The applicant has therefore not made out a serious question to be tried. Even if the applicant did have standing, a serious question to be tried has not been made out on the merits of its allegations. Application dismissed.

Held: As the applicant has not made out a seriously arguable case, it is not appropriate to grant prospective costs. Application dismissed.