R v M - [2026] NZHC 3425

Date of Judgment

23 October 2026

Decision

R v M (PDF 237 KB)

Summary

Sentencing of mother (M) for manslaughter by omission to provide necessaries to six-year-old daughter (D) (Crimes Act 1961, ss 160(2)(b), 150A and 152). D had complex medical needs. M knew certain symptoms meant D needed urgent medical attention. D developed symptoms over three days in care of M’s sister [A]. M and A texted each other about them by neither took D to hospital. D likely not to have died if given prompt medical attention.

Starting point of four years and three months adopted. Relevant factors: D’s vulnerability, breach of trust, serious long-term harm, temporal extent of inaction. Reduced slightly to account for M’s mental health issues at time.

Allowance of 25% given for guilty plea, 10% of background, 10% for remorse and rehabilitation, 10% for impact imprisonment would have on other children (M single mother).

Nominal end sentence of 1 year and 11 months’ imprisonment.

Held, home detention appropriate. Offending very context-specific and greater societal interest in M remaining with other children.

Sentence of 12 months home detention imposed.

See R v A [2026] NZHC 3426 for sentencing of sister.