Print this page

Clive Richard Bradbury and Gregory Alan Peebles v Commissioner of Inland Revenue - SC 87/2014

Summary

Civil Appeal – Whether the High Court has jurisdiction to set aside a decision which has been the subject of an appeal – Whether the Court of Appeal erred in its approach to indemnity costs – Whether the proceeding involves substantial relitigation of issues already determined by the courts.[2014] NZCA 350 CA 623/103

Result

The application for leave to appeal is dismissed. Costs are reserved.  If the respondents wish to obtain orders for costs they should apply within 14 days setting out in detail the orders sought.  If such applications are made, the applicants may respond within a further 14 days.
2 December 2014
_________
Leave is granted under s 76(2) of the Insolvency Act 2006 to permit continuation of the applications for costs in respect of SC 87/2014 and SC 103/2014. We fix costs and disbursements in favour of the Commissioner of Inland Revenue in the sum of $10,653.99.
8 June 2015

Related Documents

Leave judgment - leave dismissed — CLIVE RICHARD BRADBURY AND GREGORY ALAN PEEBLES v COMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE [2014] NZSC 174 [2 December 2014] (PDF 98 KB)

Supreme court decision — Cost decision: CLIVE RICHARD BRADBURY AND GREGORY ALAN PEEBLES v COMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE [2015] NZSC 80 [8 June 2015] (PDF 151 KB)