R v Vaitohi - [2026] NZHC 2055

Sentencing for murder. V, high-ranking member of gang, planned attack on victim’s grandson from prison for retribution and deterrence of stand-over tactics against gang faction. Co defendants sourced firearm and shot victim at his address under V’s direction. S 104 engaged, planning unsophisticated but over four days, knew victim lived at target’s address (s104(1A)(b)). MPI starting point: 15 years and three months, not sophisticated but calculated planning from prison, V instrumental role although not shooter (9 month deduction for guilty plea). 17-year MPI not manifestly unjust. End sentence: Life imprisonment with 17-year MPI.